Mediation vs. Litigation
March 26, 2024

Choosing the Right Approach for Your Vermont Divorce


Even the most straightforward divorces can become emotionally charged and complicated, leaving couples struggling with decisions about how to proceed. One of the most important choices a divorcing couple must make is whether to resolve their differences through mediation or litigation. Both options have their merits, but understanding their distinct differences is critical for making a decision that aligns with your needs and goals.


What is Mediation?


Mediation is a voluntary process in which divorcing couples work with a neutral third-party mediator to resolve their disputes outside of court. The mediator facilitates communication, assists in identifying issues, and helps the parties generate solutions that are acceptable to both sides. In Vermont, mediation is often encouraged as a means of reaching a mutually satisfactory agreement while minimizing conflict and litigation costs. Some of the many benefits of mediation include: 


Control and Flexibility 


Mediation empowers couples to maintain control over the outcome of their divorce by actively participating in the decision-making process. Unlike litigation, where a judge makes decisions based on legal arguments and evidence presented in court, mediation allows couples to tailor solutions that meet their unique needs and circumstances.


Cost-Effectiveness


Mediation typically involves fewer legal fees and court costs compared to litigation. Since the process focuses on resolving issues collaboratively, it can be more efficient and less time-consuming than waiting for court dates and engaging in lengthy legal battles.


Preservation of Relationships


Mediation fosters open communication and cooperation, which can be beneficial, especially when children are involved. By working together to find solutions, couples may preserve a more amicable relationship post-divorce, which can be advantageous for co-parenting and future interactions.


What is Litigation?


Litigation involves resolving divorce-related disputes through the court system, with each party represented by their respective attorneys. In Vermont, litigation typically follows a formal process, including pleadings, discovery, hearings, and, if necessary, trial. While litigation may be necessary in cases involving significant conflict or complex legal issues, it often entails a more adversarial approach compared to mediation. That being said, litigation does offer certain benefits over mediation, including:


Legal Protections and Adjudication


Litigation provides a structured legal process wherein a judge impartially evaluates the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. This can be advantageous in cases where there are concerns about fairness or when one party is unwilling to negotiate in good faith.


Binding Decisions


In litigation, court orders are legally binding and enforceable, providing a level of certainty and finality to the resolution of divorce-related issues such as property division, child custody, and spousal support.


Legal Advocacy


Each party has the opportunity to advocate for their interests and rights through legal representation in court. Attorneys can provide valuable guidance, protect their clients' legal rights, and ensure that their voices are heard throughout the litigation process.


Choosing the Right Approach for Your Divorce


Ultimately, the decision to pursue mediation or litigation depends on your unique circumstances, including the level of cooperation between you and your spouse, the complexity of your financial and familial situation, and your desired outcome for the divorce process. While mediation offers many benefits, it may not be suitable for every situation, particularly if there are concerns about power imbalances, domestic violence, or complex legal issues.


Deppman Law, PLC — Experienced Divorce Lawyers Serving All of Vermont 


At Deppman Law, PLC, we understand that every divorce is unique, and we are committed to helping our clients navigate the process in a way that meets their needs and goals. Whether you choose mediation, litigation, or alternative dispute resolution methods, our experienced family law team is here to provide guidance, support, and advocacy every step of the way. Contact Deppman Law, PLC, today to schedule a consultation.

Understanding Vermont’s Property Disclosure Requirements

September 18, 2025
What sellers must legally share with buyers…and what happens if they don’t Selling a home or property in Vermont involves several legal steps, but one of the most important — and often overlooked — is the requirement to disclose information about the property’s condition. Unlike some states where detailed, standardized disclosure forms are required by law, Vermont takes a slightly different approach. Still, sellers are obligated to provide accurate and truthful information about the property, particularly regarding any known defects or issues that could impact its value or use. Do I Have to Disclose Defects When Selling My Property in Vermont? In Vermont, there is no statewide mandatory property disclosure form required by law. However, Vermont courts have clearly established that sellers must not make material misrepresentations or intentionally withhold information about known defects. In simple terms: you don’t have to volunteer every detail, but you can’t lie or conceal something significant. Because of this, most sellers — especially those working with real estate agents — complete a Property Information Report or another disclosure form anyway. These documents typically cover the age and condition of systems like plumbing, roofing, electrical work, heating, water supply, septic tanks, and more. Sellers may also be asked to disclose whether the home contains asbestos, lead paint, structural damage, or boundary disputes. If a seller is unsure about a particular item (like the age of a roof), they can state that they're uncertain — but they cannot knowingly provide false information. What Counts as a “Material Defect”? A material defect is any issue that could affect the value or livability of the property. Examples include: A leaky roof or foundation cracks Water damage or mold problems A malfunctioning water heater or furnace Infestations Boundary disputes or title issues Unsafe drinking water or septic system failure Hazardous materials, such as asbestos or a buried oil tank If a seller is aware of such issues and fails to disclose them — or worse, attempts to hide them — they could be held liable for fraud or misrepresentation, even after the sale has closed. What Happens If a Seller Fails to Disclose a Known Issue? If a buyer later discovers an undisclosed problem with the property, the seller could face legal consequences, such as: Paying for repairs or replacement of damaged or defective systems Compensating the buyer for a loss in the property’s market value Cancellation of the sale , in extreme cases Punitive damages if the court finds evidence of willful fraud The burden is often on the buyer to prove that the seller knew about the defect and intentionally failed to disclose it. That’s why many buyers in Vermont choose to work with qualified real estate attorneys and inspectors when purchasing property, especially when buying older or rural homes. What About “As Is” Sales? Even if a property is sold “as is,” a seller is still responsible for disclosing any known material defects. The “as is” clause simply means that the seller will not make repairs before the sale — not that they’re excused from telling the truth about the property’s condition. Best Practices for Sellers To minimize risk: Be honest about the property, even if it means disclosing costly issues. Use standardized property disclosure forms, even if not technically required. Keep records of inspections, repairs, and maintenance. Consult an attorney if you’re unsure about what to disclose. Disclosing a defect upfront is almost always cheaper — and far less stressful — than dealing with a lawsuit later. Need Legal Guidance? Buying or selling property in Vermont can be complicated, especially when it comes to disclosure obligations. At Deppman Law PLC, we help clients manage real estate transactions with clarity and confidence. Contact our office today to discuss your real estate questions and ensure your transaction is handled the right way, with the protection and peace of mind you deserve.

Gray Divorce—Unique Challenges for Couples 50 and Up in Vermont

August 20, 2025
Understanding retirement accounts, health insurance, and estate planning in later-life divorce Divorce is challenging at any age. But when it occurs later in life, it comes with a unique set of emotional, financial, and legal considerations. Known as “gray divorce,” this trend is on the rise nationwide, and Vermont is no exception. Whether it’s a couple who’s grown apart after decades together, a second marriage that didn’t work out, or an unexpected separation due to changing needs or values, older Vermonters face specific challenges when untangling their lives. If you’re over 50 and thinking about divorce — or already in the process — it's important to understand how Vermont law impacts key issues like retirement savings, health insurance, and long-term financial security. Dividing Retirement Benefits in Gray Divorce One of the biggest financial concerns for older couples is how divorce will affect retirement savings. In Vermont, retirement accounts — including 401(k)s, pensions, IRAs, or other investments — are generally considered marital property if they were earned or contributed to during the marriage. These assets are subject to equitable distribution — meaning a fair division, not necessarily an equal one. However, splitting retirement accounts is not as simple as taking a number and dividing it in half. Depending on the type of account, you may need a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) or other legal tools to divide funds without triggering taxes or penalties. A thoughtful approach is key to ensuring both spouses can maintain financial stability during retirement. Health Insurance After Divorce In a gray divorce, health insurance can be a major issue — especially if one spouse has been relying on the other’s employer-based coverage. Once the divorce is finalized, coverage typically ends for the non-employee spouse. Here are options to consider: COBRA— Allows temporary continuation of coverage (at full cost) for up to 36 months. Vermont Health Connect— Offers individual health insurance plans, sometimes with subsidies depending on income. Medicare Eligibility— If one or both spouses are 65+, Medicare may be available — but understanding enrollment timelines and supplemental coverage options matters. Making the right choice can have a significant impact on both cost and quality of care during your later years. Estate Planning Must Be Updated Many divorcing couples overlook estate planning — but for those 50 and older, it’s essential. A divorce should prompt a full review of all important documents, including: Wills and trusts Powers of attorney Health care proxies Beneficiary designations (insurance policies, retirement plans, etc.) These documents likely name a spouse in key roles — and unless updated, they may leave your ex-spouse with unintended control over your medical, financial, or estate matters. Vermont courts encourage this reassessment to ensure your future wishes are clearly and legally defined. Emotional and Lifestyle Impacts Gray divorce isn't just about finances — it's about rebuilding life at a stage when identities are deeply intertwined. Many older adults face questions like: Where will I live now? How will I manage life alone after decades of marriage? What does my social circle look like now? Navigating these questions with support — both legal and personal — can help create a healthy path forward. Legal Guidance During a Later-Life Divorce At Deppman Law PLC, we understand the financial and emotional complexities of gray divorce in Vermont. Our goal is to help you make confident, informed decisions about your future. Contact our office today to schedule a consultation and ensure that your next chapter is protected, both legally and financially.